We sell apartment buildings.  Rock Apartment Advisors CEO's BlogSee Us On YouTubeFollow Us On TwitterJoin Us On Linked In
Sign up to receive our listings
For Email Marketing you can trust

Research

The Rock Apartment Report
Table of Contents
Welcome
As we enter into 2012, changing economic, political and social trends are turning the apartment sector into an exciting place to develop and invest. This has been a long time in coming. Too much of our industry is based on stock built between 1950 and 1975, when rent control severely curtailed new apartment construction. Since then, we've dealt with real-estate speculation, a debt crisis, and a great shift of renters to home-ownership thanks to record breaking low interest rates...  more
INTRODUTION
Ontario Outlook for 2012
In 2012, the Ontario purpose-built rental apartment industry is emerging from four decades of regulation into a far brighter future. The industry defied expectations and weathered the 2008 economic crisis, emerging with lower vacancies, higher average rents, low capitalization rates, and favourable social, economic and political factors...  more
How to Prepare Your Building for Sale
If you are looking to sell your apartment building, it goes without saying that you want to get the best price for it. By and large, the market determines the price of your building. If your building has been properly marketed and exposed long enough with a competent broker, that will net you the best price for your property...  more
New Apartment Construction
Toronto is the fifth largest city in North America, and it and the province of Ontario have approximately 25,000 apartment buildings. By population and market size alone, Ontario is a major player in the North American economy. And yet most of Ontario's apartment stock was built prior to 1975. Toronto has one of the oldest and most run-down rental apartment stock on the continent...  more
CITY PROFILES - CITY OF TORONTO
Toronto (includes Old City and East York)
When the five cities and one borough of Metropolitan Toronto were amalgamated into the City of Toronto in 1997, Toronto became not only the largest city in Canada but the fifth largest in North America. Toronto's more than quarter million apartment units are in heavy demand, making the city the centre of the Canadian apartment universe, with vacancy rates below 3% and dropping, and average rents ranging from $778 for bachelor apartments to $1346 for 3 bedrooms...  more
North York
After the Old City of Toronto, the former City of North York is the largest market for rental apartments in the Greater Toronto Area. Despite seeing most of its growth following the Second World War, unlike its surrounding neighbours, or even Etobicoke or Scarborough, the borough-turned-city invested heavily in high rise rental apartments. As a result, a total of 66,835 units can be found in North York's apartment universe as of October 2010, serving its population of 635,220...  more
Scarborough
With only 34,059 apartment units to its 602,575 people, the former City of Scarborough has the lowest concentration of apartments in the amalgamated City of Toronto (5.65 per 100 people). In spite of this, Scarborough has the lowest average rents of the city. Although these rents have been growing by an average of 0.91% per year, the provincial average has been catching up, such that in 2010, the average rent for an apartment in Scarborough was only $4.48 above the weighted provincial average...  more
Etobicoke and York
It's in the neighbourhoods of the old cities of Etobicoke and York where the bulk of the City of Toronto's apartment supply has grown in the past five years. Currently boasting 47,984 units (a concentration of 8.06 units per 100 people), these neighbourhoods have added supply in three of the past five years, with an average growth of 366 units per year...  more
CITY PROFILES - GREATER TORONTO AREA
Oshawa
The four regional municipalities surrounding the City of Toronto - Halton, Peel, York and Durham - have seen spectacular growth in the past fifty years. Until the 1960s, these former counties were primarily rural townships surrounding well established small towns. However, development spilled past the boundaries of Metropolitan Toronto, and managing that growth became the great challenge of the Province of Ontario, which created the regional municipalities in response...  more
Pickering, Ajax, Whitby & Uxbridge
With a combined population of 344,050, the cities of Pickering and Whitby, along with the town of Ajax and the township of Uxbridge in the Region of Durham have one of the lowest concentrations of apartments in the province, with only 4,346 units in the universe, or 1.26 apartments per 100 people...  more
Markham
The City of Markham, located at the City of Toronto's border in the southeastern corner of York Region, has seen rapid growth since the 1960s when Toronto's urban sprawl spread across its boundaries. In the past four years, Markham's population has grown by 14.7%, reaching 300,000 people...  more
Vaughan/King/Richmond Hill
Located north of the City of Toronto, the City of Vaughan, the Town of Richmond Hill and the Township of King have seen explosive growth from urban sprawl spilling across Toronto's boundaries. Vaughan's population has doubled in the past 20 years, to 239,000 people, making it the fastest growing municipality of Canada. Richmond Hill boasts 191,000 residents, a 17% increase in the past five years. Although the population of King Township is one-tenth that of Vaughan, it has been growing rapidly as well, with much of that growth concentrated in the urban centres of King City, Nobleton and Schomberg. The township expects the population of King City to double, reaching 12,000 by 2021...  more
Northeast York Region (Newmarket & Aurora)
The towns of Newmarket and Aurora are old settlements that were established over a century ago as development crept north from Toronto along Yonge Street. These centres became the core of post-war development as urban sprawl spread beyond Toronto's boundaries. Most of this development followed Yonge Street, although the arrival of Highway 404 and two northern GO trains have increased growth. As of 2010, Newmarket had a population of 74,295 and Aurora a population of 42,629...  more
Barrie
The City of Barrie, an established centre at the edge of the Greater Toronto Area. It is a regional centre for health, education, commerce, government and policing. Barrie has seen explosive growth since 1991. The city's population doubled between 1991 and 2006, where it now boasts 128,430. Between 2001 and 2006, the Barrie census metropolitan area was the fastest growing in Canada, outpacing Calgary, Edmonton, Toronto and Kitchener-Waterloo...  more
Mississauga
Located west of the amalgamated City of Toronto, the City of Mississauga is a mature suburban market of 734,000 residents and 26,997 apartment units (3.68 units per 100 people). This is below the provincial median, but above younger suburban municipalities like Brampton or Vaughan...  more
Brampton
Located north of Mississauga, the City of Brampton resembles its larger southern neighbour as it was ten years ago. Amalgamated by the province in 1974, it saw its rush of development come later, after more of Mississauga was developed. Its growth since 1990 has been rapid, however; between 2006 and 2011, Brampton has grown 16.4%. It is estimated that Brampton's population in 2011 is 504,900. Unlike Mississauga, it still has room to sprawl, but developable land is running out, and the city is planning to intensify...  more
Oakville
Oakville is one of the most exciting areas in Ontario in terms of development potential. After two decades of rapid growth, the city is consolidating its gains with a diversifying economy and a new regional development plan. Incomes in the city are already among the highest in Canada, unemployment is below the provincial average, and these trends are expected to continue for the foreseeable future...  more
Milton/Halton Hills
Located west of Mississauga and north of Oakville, the towns of Milton and Halton Hills have been primarily rural communities at the edge of Toronto's urban sprawl. This past decade, however, thanks to their strong transportation connections with the rest of the Greater Toronto Area, these two communities - Milton especially - have seen explosive growth. Milton's population in 2006 was set at 53,939, a 71.4% increase from 2001...  more
CITY PROFILES - HAMILTON-NIAGARA
Hamilton
The Hamilton-Niagara region contains the census metropolitan areas of Hamilton, St. Catharines-Niagara and Brantford. Lying at the western edge of the Greater Toronto Area, these CMAs contain well-established industrial and agricultural towns and cities. The area's natural beauty, particularly the Niagara Escarpment, have also helped to foster tourism. The age of these cities have served to increase their apartment stock, giving the whole area a good sized market of 57,285 units. It has also raised vacancies and kept rents low...  more
St. Catharines
The Region of Niagara, containing the cities of St. Catharines and Niagara Falls, have ridden a roller coaster ride of job growth and losses. Gains made in four out of the last six years have been offset by two particularly bad years in 2006 and 2009. Overall, the region has lost 300 jobs since 2005, but has seen employment grow by as much as 7,300 jobs in a year, and shrink by as much as 15,300...  more
Niagara Falls
In spite of its striking natural amenities (not just including the falls), in spite of its importance as a major power generator, and in spite of the government services that come from being a major crossing point between Canada and the United States, the City of Niagara Falls has not escaped the malaise that appears to have struck other border towns like Windsor or Cornwall...  more
Burlington
While much of the rental picture within the Hamilton CMA is cool, the City of Burlington - located northeast of Hamilton at the west end of the Greater Toronto Area - strongly bucks that trend. On every metric, Burlington outperforms its neighbours. Vacancy rates are half of what are to be found in Hamilton, and average rents are over $400 higher, well above the provincial average. Best of all, Burlington's apartment market is large and growing, boasting a respectable 7,960 units (4.68 units per 100 people, and an increase of 318 units over the past five years), well above the heated market available in neighbouring Oakville...  more
Brantford
The City of Brantford has come a long way from its troubled period in the 1990s when a severe downturn in the economy closed plants, raised unemployment, and caused a significant amount of decay within its downtown core. Although the 2008 recession raised unemployment again (employment has risen and fallen but overall remained static since 2009), investments in the education and services sector have breathed new life into Brantford's inner city. Its population in 2006 of 90,192 is an encouraging increase from its population in 1991 (81,997)...  more
CITY PROFILES - EASTERN ONTARIO
Ottawa
Eastern Ontario, stretching from Port Hope in the west to Algonquin Park in the north and the Quebec border in the east is, along with the Niagara region, the oldest settled area of Ontario. In spite of this, eastern Ontario is a very rural part of the province, featuring mostly small towns with small apartment markets...  more
Kingston
Located in eastern Ontario where Lake Ontario meets the St. Lawrence River, the City of Kingston isn't a large centre (city population of 117,207 in 2006; CMA population of 152,358). Its centuries' long history, including a period as the capital of the colony of Canada, gives it a downtown core steeped in heritage, and the challenge of re-inventing itself as economies change over time. Currently, the economy is heavily based on the education and government sectors, including a military base and training centre (Royal Military College), a major university, and a large corrections centre...  more
Belleville
Located halfway between Toronto and Kingston, the City of Belleville is a small urban centre of 48,821. An established centre with significant industrial development, especially in food processing, the town is able to boast strong household incomes ($61,100). Its history and early growth have built a moderate sized apartment market with 5,706 units in its universe, a high concentration of 11.68 apartments per 100 people. Although the majority of these units are in buildings of 20 units or smaller, there are at least 20 buildings of 50 units or more...  more
Peterborough
Located northeast of the Greater Toronto Area, the city of Peterborough has thus far avoided becoming a bedroom community serving Toronto's urban sprawl. However, its distance may have isolated it economically...  more
CITY PROFILES - SOUTHWESTERN ONTARIO
Waterloo
While southwestern Ontario is not as large an apartment market as the City of Toronto, nor does it have the runaway growth of the rest of the Greater Toronto Area, exciting things are happening here. Southwestern Ontario has emerged into the 21st century with a vibrant economy based on high-tech, biotech and other high-skill, high-return industries...  more
Kitchener
With 17,946 units in its universe (a concentration of 8.77 units per 100 people), the city of Kitchener's apartment market is larger and more concentrated than all of the other cites and townships in the region combined...  more
Cambridge
The City of Cambridge, with its 4,761 units in its apartment universe (3.96 units per 100 people, the lowest concentration in southwestern Ontario), has not had the benefits the City of Waterloo has had in heating up its apartment market. The city's nearest post-secondary institution, Conestoga College, is far from its three downtown cores. Cambridge's economy is heavily based on manufacturing, with carmaker Toyota being a major employer. As a result, the city has had to cope with the resulting economic downturn following the 2008 recession. Vacancy rates have reflected this trend. Starting at a region high of 3.3% in 2006, vacancy rates hit 5.6% in 2009, before falling back to 4.3%...  more
Guelph
The City of Guelph is a small urban centre located at the northwestern edge of the Greater Toronto Area. In 2006, its census metropolitan area had a population of 114,943, an increase of 8.26% over 2001. While it is far from jobs in the GTA, the city is seeing a growing number of commuters, and transportation connections are improving between the city and the GTA...  more
London
London is a significant urban centre in southwestern Ontario, the largest city between Hamilton and Detroit. Although recently overshadowed by the growth of Waterloo Region, London's population of 352,395 continues to grow at a rate of around 1% of year. It boasts a diverse economy based on skilled trades, health care, manufacturing and education. Its location at the junction of Highways 401 and 402 enhance the importance of the transportation sector on its economy...  more
Article: Cherryhill Village
Cherryhill Village is a large apartment community containing 13 high rise buildings and 2326 rental units, along with a medical building and a mall. On March 1, 2011, this community was purchased by the Minto Group from the locally founded ESAM Group in one of the largest single transactions in apartments in Canadian history. ROCK Advisors Inc., were brokers on the deal, bringing ESAM and Minto together...  more
Windsor
Windsor, an industrial city of 216,473 has had a difficult decade, losing over 12,000 jobs since 2006. The well-established apartment market of 14,651 units (6.77 units per 100 people) went into the 2008 recession with some of the highest vacancy rates in the province, and the downturn pushed vacancies to astonishing levels. By 2008, the vacancy rate for the whole census metropolitan area was 14.6%. Although very much a buyer's market, the high vacancy rates and dropping rents meant low rates of return for individuals who took the risk...  more
Sarnia
Like Windsor, Sarnia is a moderate-sized urban centre located on Canada's border with Michigan. A well-established town that still depends heavily on the petrochemical industry, Sarnia has had its problems in the past, but has managed to avoid the economic doldrums that has afflicted its larger sister city. It boasts a sizable apartment market of 5,434 units - mostly in small buildings of 50 units or less - which translates to a concentration of 7.6 units per 100 people...  more
CITY PROFILES - NORTHERN ONTARIO
Sudbury
Northern Ontario is often forgotten when investors outside the resource sector look at Ontario. The cities are small, and the area has a reputation for volatility that comes with resource-based economies. The apartment industry is no different, with more attention paid to the heated centres in the south than the cold prospects of the north...  more
North Bay
The city of North Bay, in the southeastern corner of northern Ontario, may be a surprising location for a hot apartment market. This city of 53,966, established in 1895, has grown up on the shores of Lake Nippissing, initially in service of northerly expanding railways and growing rich from the mining of silver in Cobalt...  more
Sault Ste. Marie
Located where Lake Superior meets Lake Huron, Sault Ste. Marie is a city of 74,948 people and the third largest city in northern Ontario. Since its incorporation in 1888, the city has grown around transportation, trade and steel making, thanks to its place on the St. Lawrence Seaway and its border crossing with Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan...  more
Thunder Bay
A well-established industrial city on the shores of Lake Ontario, Thunder Bay boasts a population of 109,140 (122,907 in its CMA), making it the second largest city in northern Ontario. Since the 1850s, the city has grown as a transportation centre, a vital link between the St. Lawrence Seaway and western Canada, and a major industrial centre in its own right, manufacturing subway cars and forest products. Thunder Bay boomed up to the 1960s, but then a shift in shipping from rail to roads diminished the city's importance as a port...  more
EPILOGUE
Student Housing
There has never been a better time to invest in student rental housing in Ontario. The market is booming in many centres in this province, resulting in big transactions and new construction...  more
How to minimize your income taxes
Taxes are a critical issue when it comes to selling your property, but it is one that most building owners rarely consider until it comes time to sell. This can cause some difficulties when trying to make a deal and agree on a fair price, so owners should consider the tax implications of a sale of their real estate long before they decide its time to sell...  more
Buy-side Brokerage
In the apartment marketplace, a brokerage method popular in Europe is gaining traction in Canada, connecting interested investors with willing owners. Buy-Side Brokerage is changing the way apartments are sold in Canada and easing the difficult process of buying and selling properties for both the buyer and seller alike...  more

Welcome from Derek Lobo


TO OUR VALUED CLIENTS:

As we enter into 2012, changing economic, political and social trends are turning the apartment sector into an exciting place to develop and invest. This has been a long time in coming. Too much of our industry is based on stock built between 1950 and 1975, when rent control severely curtailed new apartment construction. Since then, we've dealt with real-estate speculation, a debt crisis, and a great shift of renters to home-ownership thanks to record breaking low interest rates. But no more.

Today, demand in apartment stock is increasing. Vacancy rates are dropping and average rents are rising. Our capitalization rates are increasingly favorable. The political landscape has changed, reducing regulatory restrictions on new rents. Apartments came through the 2008 recession stronger than ever, and investors holding apartment stock have found the industry to be a safe asset class, outperforming many other investment classes in this sector. Today, investors willing to take the leap in developing new stock or renovating old stock are bound to reap the reward of a revitalized, strong and stable sector. All investors need is the will.

We have always considered the United States to be the leader and trendsetter of the apartment industry. Canadian investors, managers and developers can learn from their American counterparts. For this reason, ROCK Advisors has planned a guided tour of USA properties with formal and informal sessions with colleagues, brokers and industry professionals in April 2012 in Dallas. We hope you will be able to join us.

To assist you in planning and executing a successful investment strategy, we are pleased to present our 2011/2012 ROCK Apartment Report for the province of Ontario. This report includes our Provincial Apartment Index, a forward-looking ranking of the 31 largest markets in the province based on the economic, supply and demand conditions of each, and on our knowledge of the local marketplace. We hope that this resource will help you in making the best development choices and to get the best return for your investment dollar.

We would like to thank our friends in the industry who have provided their professional insight for this report. These include Phil Deschenes, Brian Knowles, Sandy Mandel, Janet Moorefield and Carey Poon. We would also like to thank our sponsors, without whose support this report would not have been possible.

2011 is the ROCK Advisors' 25th year in the apartment industry, and we are very grateful to our clients across North America who have given us the opportunity to serve them. To these people we say, thank you. We hope you will find this report useful, and our investment professionals at ROCK look forward to assisting you in meeting your goals.


Sincerely,

Derek A. Lobo ,
CEO, Sales Representative
dlobo@rockaptadvisors.ca
Solo Deo Gloria

Preparing Your Building For Sale


How to Prepare Your Apartment Building for Sale

If you are looking to sell your apartment building, it goes without saying that you want to get the best price for it. By and large, the market determines the price of your building. If your building has been properly marketed and exposed long enough with a competent broker, that will net you the best price for your property. The two basic strategies to get your best price include enticing investors by showing them good returns are possible, and protecting your deal by limiting your liabilities revealed during a sale. From these, vendors have a number of steps they can take to maximize their return.

1) Get your paperwork in order.

As apartment real estate transactions generate a ton of paperwork, frustrating both you and the buyer, do some of the work in advance. For example, pay for a structural engineering inspection and issue the report in advance of selling your property. Be sure that all paperwork is ready for due diligence. This way, the buyer can't come back for an unjustified price cut because all the capital expenditure work is quantified, and there's less chance a surprise will spook the buyer.

2) Keep your property clean

We mean more than just tending to your building's curb appeal. You need to be aware of the environmental conditions of your property. Update your building's Phase One environmental report before you sell. Here, an environmental engineer will look at your building to check for signs of hazardous substances like asbestos, or the presence of old oil storage tanks, et cetera. This is related to the step of getting your paperwork in order. It can be a nasty surprise to discover environmental issues on your property during due diligence, but it is better to find them before you sell rather than while you sell. These have to be remedied, or else you will not get any financing for your deal.

3) Get your financing in order.

This is a step you should be taking even if you aren't currently planning to sell your property. Most owners don't plan on selling, but many do because of situations beyond their control (economy, partnerships, market circumstances), and it is more than frustrating to have sales blocked because the existing financing isn't flexible enough or can't be modified. Depending on market conditions, penalties for breaking long term mortgages can seriously hamper your bottom line. This also applies to your income taxes. Too many owners aren't prepared for the recapture and capital gains taxes that will come due on a sale. You should have money set aside to meet these contingencies, or you should prepare yourself to sell your property in a way that limits these liabilities. Our article on How To Minimize your Taxes gives you a good rundown of what you
can expect from the taxman, and how you can minimize or defer the taxes payable on a sale.

4) Start retrofitting your building to show improvements.

If you haven't done this for your building yet, start installing low-flow toilets or aeration devices on showerheads and kitchen faucets. Start retrofitting your lighting systems. Make sure your fire safety is up to date. Also, start renovating key suites and raising rents accordingly.
This approach falls into the category of enticing investors by showing them the possible returns your building can generate. If you lower utility costs and raise rents enough and show an increase in your property's net income, potential investors can see that there is a good potential return on their investment, and they will pay more for your property.
Some investors make a lot of money by buying properties and maximizing their increase in net income before selling at a much higher price. They start considering how best to sell their property even as they buy it, going as far as appealing their building's taxes to try and reduce costs as much as possible. You might not have to go this far, but showing your property in its best condition includes its financial condition as well as its physical condition.

5) Inform key people about the sale and get them on board.

Staff are part of the street-to-suite experience that potential buyers will be looking at as they assess your property. They will be in contact with these buyers and they will have to make a good impression with them, so it is important to motivate these people into getting behind a sale. Possible ways to do this include offering a bonus to staff members upon selling, or reminding staff that each buying tour is a potential job interview and that they should dress accordingly.

6) Choose a good broker.

Preparing you building for sale can take some time, so it helps to bring in a professional early to manage this process. Choose a broker you trust with a good reputation who is well known in the marketplace, with experience in the industry who has built up a good relationship with the potential buyers in your market. Be sure that the broker has a strong database of building owners and potential buyers. Brokers with good knowledge of the industry will find the most qualified buyers looking for exactly the property you are selling, and getting you top dollar for your property.

New Apartment Construction


It's Now Cheaper to Build Apartments than Buy Them

Toronto is the fifth largest city in North America, and it and the province of Ontario have approximately 25,000 apartment buildings. By population and market size alone, Ontario is a major player in the North American economy. And yet most of Ontario's apartment stock was built prior to 1975. Toronto has one of the oldest and most run-down rental apartment stock on the continent. It does not have to be this way. A long history of punitive rent controls has ended, and new apartment buildings are not rent controlled.
Toronto is in the midst of a high-rise boom. In 2011 alone, 16,000 new condominium units will come on the market in the Greater Toronto Area; 5,500 are being built in downtown Toronto. Clearly, demand exists for high-rise living space in our cities. ROCK Advisors recently sold six newly built apartment buildings, all of which set record prices in the cities they were sold in. All of this shows that a market exists for building and selling purpose-built rental buildings.
Part of the problem is, in 1975, the government of Ontario brought in Rent Control, virtually halting construction of new rental space throughout the province. In 1998, the situation improved when the government brought in legislation to exempt new buildings from rent controls, but the wounds run deep. Twenty-three years of stringent rent controls have forced traditional apartment developers out of the business, and so the construction drought continues.
So, condominium developers may be the people who will start building the new high-rise rental market. Condominium builders showed great skill in buying and entitling land, building projects and selling units. For condominium developers to become apartment developers, they only have to change from selling their units to renting them. Once a new building is leased up, it can be valued and sold to one of many apartment investors who would be interested in buying a newly constructed building.
For condominium developers, the prospect of building rental apartments offers a number of advantages:
  • Purpose-built rental apartments allow the condominium developer to continue operating if and when the condominium market slows down. It creates a new stable line of business for the condominium developer.
  • Finished rental apartment buildings have an entirely new marketplace of buyers eager to snap up properties. Most prefer a fully-stabilized asset all leased up, but some may be willing to buy a vacant apartment building and do the leasing themselves.
  • CMHC financing to build apartments is available at very attractive interest rates.
  • A lease-up is virtually assured, as there are few new apartment buildings in the market, and a pent-up demand exists for purpose-built rental properties.
Any developer considering building a purpose-built rental building should undertake a feasibility study to ask and answer the following questions:
  1. Should you build?
  2. What should you build?
  3. How much can you rent the units for?
  4. How deep is the market?
While the cost of construction and low rent levels have made it difficult in the past twenty-five years to build new apartments, today rent levels have risen, cap rates have come down and interest rates are low. This combination has made apartment development profitable again, and condominium developers should seriously look at this opportunity.

The Case for Student Housing


Student Housing a Great Learning Experience

There has never been a better time to invest in student rental housing in Ontario. The market is booming in many centres in this province, resulting in big transactions and new construction.
And yet, challenges exist for student housing developers that don't exist for developers of other rental accommodations. For those developers who might be leery of the market, there are many reasons why you should overcome your fears and get investing. And there are ways you can meet the challenges and prosper.

Demographics

There are currently over 800,000 students enrolled in colleges and universities across Canada. This number is expected to grow over the next ten years, so that over a million students will be enrolling at the beginning of September 2021. Where will these students live? Not only will an additional 200,000 students be looking for accommodations, these students will be staying in school longer as they pursue more years of education.
Demand is already strong for quality student accommodations in most cities and towns with universities across Ontario and it's only going to get stronger. These factors will lead to lower vacancies and higher average rents and a high rate of return on investments.

Student Housing's Special Concerns

Student housing is a specialized market, and developers should be aware of the special characteristics of that market before they invest. It goes without saying that student housing cannot exist without a college or university to provide tenants, but few realize that no other form of real estate is as sensitive to location as student housing is. Students, many of whom are moving into their own accommodations for the first time in their lives, need to be close to their schools, and will pay a lot more for a property that has a good location.
Renting to students also means renting on a short-term basis with more tenants than conventional rental apartments. Although Ontario universities are expanding their summer term offerings, the industry is still geared heavily towards September 1st, and the summer term is a challenging time to keep apartments occupied.
Further, students and their parents also want a quality product that's well managed. Fewer students these days are willing to accept overcrowded houses in student ghettos, and neither are the non-student residents in the neighbouring properties, nor the city councils they elect.
Purpose-built student housing which offers updated amenities like fully-equipped fitness centres, access to movie theatres, game rooms, study rooms, et cetera, are already renting for a considerable premium over other stock. These buildings should also be designed for high tenant density, with multiple bedrooms, fully equipped kitchens, and other amenities one would typically find in a mid-range condominium building, including flat screen TVs and double beds.
Developers building one or two-bedroom apartments for students do not have an understanding of the market they're building into. Students are looking for privacy and community, which means well designed four-bedroom, two-bathroom units should be the norm. Be sure that the bedroom doors lock.

Higher Costs, Higher Rates of Return

Although student housing has been stigmatized in the past for being of poor quality unable to stand up to the rigours students put on it (and this is still a factor when it comes to insuring your student properties), student housing is a more management intensive investment, than conventional rental housing. More people will occupy a student apartment's rooms over the course of the year in student housing. Parents will visit, friends will come over, and many will stay overnight as they cram for exams at the end of term. This will lead to increased wear and tear on the building that management has to be prepared for.
However, most students these days have significant disposable income. Not only do many students have jobs, they often have parents and two sets of grandparents willing to help them take this first step on adult life. They are willing to pay for the amenities the landlords provide. A well-designed product can get you more dollars per square foot than a conventional apartment, easily offsetting the costs of additional amenities and security. Simply said, today's students have more money. They drink Heinekin.

The Case for Student Housing


The Best Places to Build

Developers building student housing will find their best returns in cities with institutions where the majority of students are from out of town, such as Queen's University in Kingston or the University of Waterloo. Schools like George Brown College in Toronto have students that commute to class. So although George Brown is still a good place to invest, be aware that the percentage of the student population which needs housing is lower than schools elsewhere.
When considering which institutions to invest near, look at the existing student housing demand, and consider the school's future enrolment projections, and whether competition will be opening up nearby. The provincial government recently announced a plan to establish new undergraduate campuses in cities without a university presence, such as Barrie. Oshawa has already seen the launch of a new downtown campus of the University of Ontario Institute of Technology. Such initiatives will spark a new market for student housing in those areas.
Developers also need to be aware of the various barriers to entry that might exist in certain towns with universities or colleges. Some cities, like Waterloo, have embraced student housing and encouraged its growth through favourable bylaws and an expedited development process. Other towns are still struggling with the question of student housing, causing tension between students and local residents.

A Growing Market

But the market is encouraged and encouraging in more places than it's not. The growth of the student population over the next decade, the increasing affluence of said students, and their willingness to pay for the best quality stock on offer all translates into excellent returns for those willing to take the leap into the student housing market.

How to Minimize Your Taxes


Minimizing Taxes on Sale or Inter-Generational Transfer

Taxes are a critical issue when it comes to selling your property, but it is one that most building owners rarely consider until it comes time to sell. This can cause some difficulties when trying to make a deal and agree on a fair price, so owners should consider the tax implications of a sale of their real estate long before they decide its time to sell.

Recapture Taxes

In owning a building, taxes arise in two forms: the recapture of depreciation taken, and the capital gain. Recapture of depreciation occurs after a building owner uses the capital depreciation of his or her asset as an expense to reduce his or her income taxes. When they do this, the amount of depreciation is subtracted from the original cost of the building, and the amount that remains is the undepreciated capital cost or UCC.
When a building is sold, the building's original cost less UCC is fully taxable to a vendor at income tax rates. This can be a painful surprise to anybody who isn't expecting to pay such a tax. Building owners should remember that using depreciation doesn't eliminate income tax; it only defers it, and this decision can come back to haunt them when the time comes to sell.

Capital Gains

The other major tax that vendors will have to deal with when they sell is a Capital Gains Tax. This occurs when properties increase in value over time. When they sell, the difference between the value of their property at the time of sale, and its original cost, will be taxable at capital gains rates.
Vendors need to be aware when they sell their property, that they will be taxed on the full increase in its value. This can be a significant portion of a vendors net proceeds, especially if a vendor has a large mortgage, perhaps due to refinancing of their property over time. While capital gains tax rates are lower than income tax rates, they can still be a painful surprise to any vendor who isn't prepared.

Deemed Disposition

And the taxman will get you in the end. On the passing of a 2nd spouse, an owner's estate will face a deemed disposition of all of its assets. This means the estate will be deemed to have sold everything, and all taxes inherent in the assets will be due, including both recapture and capital gain on any property held by the estate. Unless you have set aside money or have otherwise planned for this event, your children or grandchildren may end up on the hook for the tax bill. They may be forced to sell your asset at less than what it's worth or assume further mortgages.
It is therefore that much more important that building owners deal with their tax issues while they are alive, and not leave the burden for their loved ones.

The Long-Term Lease

With careful planning, there are ways to limit or defer the taxes owed on the sale of your properties. One option could be to negotiate a long-term lease. Here, rather than selling a property, a vendor leases the rights to it for a pre-set term -- up to 99 years. In this arrangement, the vendor gets a guaranteed income stream over the course of the lease, and as a sale did not occur, recapture and capital gains taxes are deferred. This is not a popular option however, as buyers do not get full ownership of the property, and vendors do not receive full proceeds of a sale.

Share Sale

Another option to minimize taxes is to, instead of selling a property, sell shares in a company that owns the property. Most owners hold their property in corporations, and a sale of shares rather than the property itself converts the recapture tax to a capital gains tax. However, share buyers know that they will be on the hook for the low cost base in the assets, and that they may have very little ability to depreciate the asset further. As a result, a buyer will demand a discount for the embedded tax in the asset.

Share Swap

If selling shares isn't favored, why not exchange shares instead? This is handy if you are dealing with a large public company. Rather than paying cash, a corporate buyer will offer shares equal in value to your property's equity, effectively exchanging your property for portions of other properties in the buyer's portfolio. Selling those shares at a later date will still leave you liable for capital gains, however it provides for a deferral. The biggest risk here is losing control of your money and possible volatility in the value of the newly acquired public shares.

Other Strategies

Other strategies range from the simple to the sophisticated. Expert advice is needed to minimize your taxes.

Buy-Side Brokerage


Buy-Side Brokerage - Better, Smarter

In the apartment marketplace, a brokerage method popular in Europe is gaining traction in Canada, connecting interested investors with willing owners. Buy-Side Brokerage is changing the way apartments are sold in Canada and easing the difficult process of buying and selling properties for both the buyer and seller alike.
Buying an apartment in a high-demand, low-supply market can be challenging, so it's important for investors to find a broker to take them through the process.
In the apartment market, there are three types of brokers one can use:
  • The Traditional Method Broker - Here, like a standard housing real-estate transaction, a broker is commissioned by the seller to list a building to the general marketplace. Investors are left to investigate the building themselves and decide whether the investment is right for them.
  • The Off-Market Method Broker - Here, brokers approach potential sellers and ask if they'd like to sell their buildings. If the building owner is open to potential offers, he or she may allow the broker to show the building, discreetly, to potential buyers.
  • Finally, there is the Buy-Side Broker, who is approached by an investor, told what type of building the investor wants, and is paid to go searching. Once the broker finds a building that meets the investor's criteria, negotiations are opened and an offer is made. The seller benefits by discovering an investor who is very interested in the property, and the investor benefits by finding exactly the building he or she is looking for.
With over 25,000 apartment buildings in the Ontario marketplace, finding the one that's best for an investor is a daunting task, but the buy-side broker takes the stress out of the search. Investors looking to hire such brokers should keep the following things in mind:

1. List criteria in detail.

This is the most important step. For the broker to do his or her job, he or she must know where the investor wants to buy, what type of building to buy, how big a building to buy, and so on. The broker also needs to know that the investor has a strong mandate to buy, or else all this work will go to waste.

2. Be sure broker uses an up-to-date database

A broker is only as good as his or her knowledge of the marketplace. The best brokers in Ontario have databases that list every apartment building in the province as well as other provinces. This database should be able to quickly list all buildings within a particular city, of a particular size, and the limiting attributes.

3. Be sure broker surveys potential properties

The best brokers send out surveyors to investigate candidate buildings that turn up in a database search. These buildings are scored on characteristics favourable to a renter's experience, including good superintendents, curb appeal, quality of the lobby and common areas, overall apartment appeal, ocation, security, parking and other amenities.
Buildings are ranked by the above criteria, and then compared against the rents they charge. It is not always the case that the best quality buildings charge the highest rents. As seen in the graphic above, the big differences between quality and rent charged is where the biggest returns can be found.
Once these steps are taken, the broker presents the findings to the investor, who chooses the building he or she wants and makes an offer. Even though the rents may not offer the immediate returns the investor wants, the investor should be aware that rents can be raised when tenants move out, and the investment can yield much higher returns over time.

4. Let the Broker Bring Investors and Sellers Together

In buy-side brokerage, the broker approaches building owners on behalf of a buyer to present an unsolicited offer from a qualified and interested buyer. The building owners are often pleasantly surprised by the attention, since they can now sell their property with no risk, no listing, no obligation, and for a higher price than they might otherwise have received using other broker methods. The broker negotiates the agreement in full confidentiality, and the building is sold.
By connecting investors looking to buy and owners looking to sell, this method provides the best rate of return for both investors and sellers.

Coming Soon


This section of the Rock Report will be available shortly.